Should We Believe Experts?

by Stephen Mills on April 9, 2012

The answer to that question is complicated and my answer is usually yes, but you have to be careful.  We live in an age of explosive growth of knowledge.  Much of it comes to us in the form of truth claims.  Many of those claims are irrelevant to our lives, but some of them aren’t and some of them may are quite important.  We all have busy lives and we can’t be experts at everything so in the end we have to rely upon the real experts, but we have to be very careful in how we do so.

Imagine you are sitting on a jury and you are presented with a prosecution and a defense expert that are saying very different things.  You are forced to choose between them but other than their presentation you have no basis on which to know which is correct.  It could be that 99 out of 100 relevant experts in the field would agree with the prosecution expert, but the hired-gun by the defense sounds very persuasive.  You don’t know this information on expert consensus, but you are still forced to choose between them.

This same scenario confronts us almost daily.  The media while trying to be balanced will often present “both sides” of an issue and leave one with the impression that it is controversial when in reality there might be a consensus of opinion among the relevant experts.  Search engines rank results on the popularity of the pages and not on their accuracy.  They don’t know who is correct so you may do a search and end up with a bunch of pages spewing quackery at the top of your results.

We also have a bunch of experts that end up being popular with the media.  Dr. Oz is a medical doctor and obviously knows more about medicine in general than I do.  However, the advice he dispenses is not always backed up by strong science.  Dr. Oz came to prominence because he had a very important fan named Oprah.  That doesn’t mean you should trust what Dr. Oz says.

You should almost never trust just one expert.  Given that we can’t be experts on everything ourselves, we ultimately have to trust those people who are expert in the relevant fields.  But we need to understand what the majority of experts believe on any given issue.  That doesn’t mean the majority is always right, but given that we are unlikely to have the expertise to be able to determine that ourselves (otherwise we would be experts), the most rational thing to do is usually to go with the majority.

It matters whether that majority is 60/40 or 90/10.  If 90% of climatologists believe that the earth is warming (I’ve recently read that number is now 97.5%) and that at least part of that is due to human activities, the odds of a non-expert like you or I being able to determine that the other 10% are correct and the overwhelming majority wrong is very slim. You don’t have the expertise to do that despite what you read on the Internet.  If you did you would be a climatology expert and a very elite one at that.  Just because you can find experts on the other side of an issue doesn’t mean it’s rational to believe them.  Years ago I had serious doubts about warming of the earth.  Now I don’t.

Determining just who are the experts sometimes is not easy.  For example, there is a difference between nutritionists and nutritional scientists doing real scientific research or reviewing the research of others.  Your local pastor may claim to know the age of the universe based upon what he reads in his holy book, but you probably should go with the consensus of the elite theoretical physicists on that one.

In the end you are responsible for your own decisions.  However, just because you read an article on the Internet or because the people you agree with yell louder than the other side doesn’t make them right.  Like everyone else I have my own biases and preferences.  I like to find some intelligent expert who agrees with my position and thereby confirm my own bias.  That is very easy to do in the age of the Internet.  When I find myself inclined to do so, I have to force myself to behave more rationally.

What To Do?

My advice can be summarized as follows:

  • If something is very, very important to you, then you should spend considerable time learning and understanding the issues involved.  You should be able to speak reasonably well about what the evidence is and why the various experts believe as they do.  If you are going against the majority, especially if that is a strong majority, you should have very, very good reasons.
  • For most things you care about but aren’t as important as the first category you simply are not going to have enough time to gain the expertise to make rational decisions for yourself.  You need to rely on the experts whether you want to or not.  If there is not a strong majority either way, say at least 2 to 1, then there may be no good basis upon which to decide and choosing either could be considered rational.  If there is a strong majority then you are probably being irrational to not go with that majority.  In that case you are claiming to be an expert that is more expert than most experts.
  • For things where you have to decide but aren’t that important.  Do whatever you feel like!

For me it sucks to admit most relevant experts disagree with what I would like to believe.  This happens to me fairly often.  I’m just admitting I don’t have any rational basis to think I know more than they do no matter how I feel.


Get Free Updates to The Rat Race Trap by Email here or via a reader in the top left sidebar.  I would love to have you on board.

If you liked this article and think it might be useful to others please share by clicking the share buttons below:

{ 10 trackbacks }
June 17, 2013 at 12:58 pm
target coupon codes
May 1, 2014 at 9:47 am
binary options daily picks
May 5, 2014 at 12:31 pm
May 8, 2014 at 11:07 pm
diamond dash free game
June 2, 2014 at 7:13 am
June 9, 2014 at 4:19 pm
aspergers autism
July 3, 2014 at 6:21 am
google adwords express
September 24, 2014 at 1:56 am
look at here now
October 14, 2014 at 7:52 pm
youtube marketing strategies
October 16, 2014 at 2:41 am

{ 16 comments… read them below or add one }

Juanita A. Leech May 29, 2012 at 1:43 am

Weather I like it or not I have to believe in the experts, they have the expertise and they work hard for it.
Juanita A. Leech´s last blog post ..joint pain causes


Mizpah May 29, 2012 at 3:49 am

I always adore the ideas that provide by the experts, they are able enough to provide the best things that can be in such thing…
Mizpah´s last blog post engine optimization


Desi Cobrev August 23, 2012 at 12:25 am

Me too. When I get idea from the experts, it gives me a wonderful result. I always getting idea from the experts.
Desi Cobrev´s last blog post ..Male Sexual Problem and How to Solve it using Natural Supplements


jennifer May 29, 2012 at 5:28 am

For me, experts are the person who are able to provide great ideas that can we use as a guide in order to make things worth possible…
jennifer´s last blog post calls


mobile emulator June 22, 2012 at 3:28 pm

Our investments are devastated, obesity is epidemic, test scores are in decline, blue-chip companies circle the drain, and popular medications turn out to be ineffective and even dangerous. What happened? Didn’t we listen to the scientists, economists and other experts who promised us that if we followed their advice all would be well?

Actually, those experts are a big reason we’re in this mess. And, according to acclaimed business and science writer David H. Freedman, such expert counsel usually turns out to be wrong–often wildly so. Wrong reveals the dangerously distorted ways experts come up with their advice, and why the most heavily flawed conclusions end up getting the most attention-all the more so in the online era. But there’s hope: Wrong spells out the means by which every individual and organization can do a better job of unearthing the crucial bits of right within a vast avalanche of misleading pronouncements.


Clayne Cook July 3, 2012 at 5:32 am

I think sometimes we need to believe to the experts since they know already what would be the outcome and they know if it is better to do. They give good advice to you to the things they are expert.
Clayne Cook´s last blog post ..Male Sex Drive: How to Increase Your Sex Drive


Lisa Hoff August 9, 2012 at 9:05 pm

I think there are times that we must need to believe in an expert. Since, they are professional on that field for sure they can give you excellent advice.
Lisa Hoff´s last blog post ..Experience the Joys of Sex


photo editing September 30, 2012 at 3:01 pm

Should we believe the ‘experts’. Because economic and social phenomena are so forbidding, or at least so seem, and because they yield few .


appliance testing October 8, 2012 at 6:31 am

We also have a bunch of experts that end up being popular with the media. Dr. Oz is a medical doctor and obviously knows more about medicine in general than I do. However, the advice he dispenses is not always backed up by strong science. Dr. Oz came to prominence because he had a very important fan named Oprah. That doesn’t mean you should trust what Dr. Oz says


Abnormal heart rhythm January 10, 2013 at 3:20 pm

Informative and precise…Its difficult to find informative and precise information but here I found…
Abnormal heart rhythm´s last blog post ..dora-the-babysitter


sandrine February 4, 2013 at 7:35 am

sometimes i believe experts not always. You cannot believe always what people say even experts.


Kennan Summers February 4, 2013 at 7:40 am

when can you call someone an expert ?


Sacramento apartment management February 9, 2013 at 2:15 pm

Hi, i think that i saw you visited my web site thus i came to ”return the favor” . I’m trying to find things to improve my website ! I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas !!


Phoenix rental property management February 21, 2013 at 10:05 am

I am very happy to find this blog.I would like to thank you for this great read!! I surely glad every little bit of it and I have bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.


Northern virginia property management in March 19, 2013 at 2:19 pm

Aw, this was a very nice post. In thought I wish to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article but what can I say I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get one thing done.


ChangQZehe July 31, 2016 at 12:11 pm

It’s perfect time to earn some plans for future years and it’s a chance to be happy.
I’ve look at this post of course, if I could I desire to suggest you some interesting things or
tips. Maybe you could write next articles talking about this informative article.
I need to read more aspects of it!
ChangQZehe´s last blog post ..ChangQZehe


Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge